The need for more bandwidth has grown more rapidly than ever
before, mainly because of the success of the Internet. In 1994 only
4% of U.S. homes were connected to the Internet. Now over 20% are
online and demand is growing fast. Although the basic building
blocks of the technology for ubiquitous bandwidth have existed for
decades, the market need has only recently reached critical mass.
As more and more applications demand greater bandwidth,
everyoneboth users and PC makerswant faster access to
the Internet. It remains only for the local phone companies to
deploy these new services. This article surveys several data access
technologies, focusing on those most likely in the near future.
In the 80s the Local Area Network (LAN) was adopted to
interconnect computers at many corporate, governmental, and
educational sites. Now that LANs are commonplace, the Wide Area
Network (WAN) is becoming an indispensable link to connect an
enterprise across longer distances. Initially WANs carried
voiceband trafficvoice calls and voiceband data modem calls.
Voiceband data modems were, and still are, the primary method of
remotely accessing a corporate LAN, or the Internet. Remote users
connected to a distant site via a modem dial-in to log-on as a
remote user or to FTP a few files. Using WANs to connect distant
LANs was relatively uncommon, since the fastest modems operated at
only 14.4 kilobits-per-second (Kbps). Higher speed data services
were only available using dedicated private line data services,
such as "switched 56K", "T1", and "frame relay". These high-speed
data connections were rarely true WAN connections, in other words,
they couldn't dial anywhere, instead they were "nailed up"
connections that tied together remote corporate LANs. Although ISDN
was developed to provide a true switched data connection, it was
never widely deployed, or used. This is changing. Today's
high-speed data WANs are becoming true switched connections, ISDN
is helping, but new services are coming that will provide an order
of magnitude increase in data price/performance to the home.
In 1995 the World Wide Web brought graphical, hypertext-linked
Internet access to every computer equipped with a modem. Today
nearly every PC user wants a higher speed data connection to the
Internet, and most users are now looking to the new 56 Kbps modems
(ISDN is still not widely available). "Modeming in" from a home
office for remote access is now an everyday occurrence for millions
of PC users.
So, how will we get more data bandwidth to the home? From the
phone company of course. Historically phone companies have relied
on voice calls to generate most of their revenue, and have been
very cautious to adopt new data services, like ISDN in the 80s.
Today however, the phone companies are running additional "plain
old telephone lines" (POTS) to homes for the second data line! This
costs money, forces area code changes, and overburdens the existing
voice switches with voiceband modem data traffic. Add it all up and
the phone companies want and need a better data service today. In
addition, the Telecommunications Act of 1996 permits competition in
the Local Exchange Carriers (LEC) market, in other words, the POTS
phone lines to homes and business. These Competitive Local Exchange
Carriers, or C-LECs, also see the opportunity to provide new
high-speed data services as a large opportunity. All told,
broadband data services will be rivaling even the venerable voice
services in terms of market size, and certainly are one of the
largest telecommunications market opportunities in decades.
Over the next five years the dominant local data services are
likely to be based on a few of the data technologies that already
exist todaynew technology isn't required. The following
sections will describe what these technologies are, and what they
do for the subscriber and the phone company.
Voiceband Modems
Voiceband modems are the most common type of modem, and by far
the most widespread: over 100 million are in daily use, and 95% of
Internet access is via voiceband modems. Voiceband modems will
remain the primary method of Internet access for many years to
come. Voiceband modems connect directly to the central office (CO)
voice switch, can dial any number and hence work on any "plain old
telephone service" (POTS) line. However, voiceband modems cannot
exceed 56 Kbps, they tie up one phone line (costing the subscriber
more), and they tie up a port on the CO voice switch. Moreover,
users often stay online for hours rather than minutes (voice calls
typically last only a few minutes). Thus they cost the CO
significantly more than voice calls, they degrade overall
performance, and they force the phone companies to upgrade their
existing expensive voice switches.
Voiceband modems have existed for almost 30 years, the earliest
being the Bell 103 transferring data at 300 bps (bits-per-second),
and more recently the V.34 (33.6 kbps or thousand bps). The fastest
voiceband modems now available use one of two technologies: K56flex
or X2. K56flex, developed by Lucent Technologies and Rockwell, is
the most widely supported 56 Kbps modem protocol today, supported
by over 700 leading PC, modem, and remote access server
manufacturers and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) worldwide. The
next voiceband modem technology standard will be V.PCM, which is a
version of 56 Kbps modems being standardized by the
Telecommunications Industry Association (TIA). V.PCM will provide
better interoperability between 56K modems from different vendors,
meaning your connection will be faster more often. It's worth
noting that 56 Kbps is the fastest speed achievable over a dial-up
POTS line. Given the limitations of the voiceband technology, these
latest "best of breed" modems will satisfy the demands of many
users until higher-speed technology becomes ubiquitous.
Figure 1: Local access with voiceband modem
ISDN Modems
The best-known form of digital telecommunications, Integrated
Services Digital Network (ISDN) is a digital network providing
voice and data communications at rates of up to 1.544 (T1 rates in
the U.S.) or 2.048 Mbps (E1 rates in Europe) for Primary Rate
Interface (PRI) service (actually slightly less since one 64 Kbps
channel is used for signaling). Many corporate users rely on
T1/E1/PRI service for Internet connectivity to link their distant
enterprise locations. Individuals in many areas can order Basic
Rate Interface (BRI) ISDN, which provides two 64 Kbps B channels
(for data or voice) and one 16 Kbps D channel (for signaling: who's
calling, number dialed, and so on). BRI modems use the existing
POTS lines to the phone company, but the CO must have ISDN line
cards installed, instead of typical POTS line cards, a substantial
expense for the phone company. Two B channels can be combined into
one 128 Kbps data channel via the BONDING technique (defined by the
Bandwidth ON Demand Interoperability Group), yielding a high-speed
data pipe for select customers. BRI can operate only up to 18,000
feet (3 miles) from the CO, limiting deployment in a service
area.
Two interface techniques are used at the subscribers' location:
the Universal (U) and the Subscriber/Termination (S/T). The U
interface plugs directly to the phone line. The S/T interface
requires a separate Network Termination (NT-1) unit to connect to
the U interface at the phone line, but it allows up to eight BRI
devices to share the line. Setting up a BRI channel can be complex,
since there are so many options to select and configure. BRI is in
many cases the best data access available at moderate cost.
Although BRI has been available for over a decade, there are fewer
than one million subscribers in the U.S. so far. Even with the
demand for Internet bandwidth, phone companies have been slow to
deploy BRI since it ties up their voice switches with lengthy data
calls. Nonetheless, as the cost comes down, and as setup becomes
more standardized, ISDN will gain more users.
Figure 2: Local access with ISDN modem
xDSL Modems
The newest and most promising digital advance, Digital
Subscriber Line (DSL) modems provide a quantum leap over ISDN or
voiceband modem data bandwidth. Asymmetric DSL (ADSL), the leading
contender, delivers up to 9 megabits-per-second (Mbps) downstream
(to the subscriber) and up to 1 Mbps upstream (to the network).
ADSL modems save the phone companies money because they combine
voice and broadband data on each existing phone line. Within five
years, a significant portion of U.S. households will have
high-speed data connections to the Internet via ADSL modems.
Following are the significant features of ADSL:
- A single local loop (the wires that transmit to the local CO)
can provide both voice and data. Life-Line voice is
retainedthe phone will work in a power outage, but the data
connection will be down. Thus only one local loop per subscriber is
required.
- Data is modulated at higher frequencies (up to 1 MHz) than
voice signals, and can be passed over 18,000 foot local loops to
the subscriber. Typical ADSL will be "rate adaptive", meaning that
the fastest connections depend on the quality and length of the
local loop.
- A splitter at both ends separates the voice (below 4000 Hz)
from the higher frequency data: voice and data to and from the user
pass over the single POTS line to the CO, where voice is sent to
the CO voice switch and data is sent to the network via ATM. Thus,
phone companies don't need to install more local loops, don't have
to buy more voice switches, and won't have degraded service due to
data traffic through their voice switches. Subscribers get better
data service, even if they're online all the time.
Figure 3: Local access with xDSL modem
Of all xDSL forms, ADSL is the most significant for mass
deployment because voice and data coexist on the same local loop.
Ironically, ADSL was first developed for digital video to the home,
but video alone did not drive up demand as the Internet has.
However, when ADSL is available, there will be virtually unlimited
video sources available to the subscriber.
| xDSL Type |
Data Throughput |
Description |
| IDSL |
64 or 128 Kbps (both directions) |
Not really a new xDSL technology, but ISDN repackaged into a
DSL-like configuration |
| SDSL (Single line DSL) |
160 Kbps to 2.084 Mbps (both directions) |
Symmetric broadband modem, good for businesses or ISPs who need
high speed data in both directions |
| HDSL (High data rate DSL) |
1.544 Mbps and 2.084 Mbps in both directions |
Provides T1 or E1 service over POTs lines |
| ADSL (Asymmetric DSL) |
Up to 9 Mbps downstream
Up to 1 Mbps upstream |
Voice and data services are tailored for mass deployment to
residential markets |
| VDSL (Very high date rate DSL) |
Up to 52 Mbps downstream
Up to 13 Mbps upstream |
Next generation modem technology for broadband data
distribution |
Table 1: Available types of xDSL technology
What Else is There?
As for cable modems, satellite modems, and wireless modems,
these are "broadcast" technologies. Broadcasting data to thousands
of subscribers does not scale for mass deployment as well as the
voiceband/ISDN/ADSL "point-to-point" modems. For example, cable and
satellite modems can send hundreds of megabits downstream (to
subscribers), but this high-speed bandwidth gets divided by the
total number of active subscribers, often hundreds or thousands,
reducing the effective bandwidth to as low as the existing
voiceband modems. In addition, the upstream connection to the
network is difficult to provide; only 7% of the existing cable TV
networks can support upstream data; and satellite transponders are
costly. Wireless offers portability but is limited to voiceband, or
lower, speeds due to the limited radio frequency bandwidth.
The universal need for faster access promises to drive further
technological innovations. More people are using 28.8 and 33.6 Kbps
modems today. The 56 Kbps limit for voiceband modems has spurred
designs that exploit the analog channel to its fullest. The K56flex
technology, for example, offers higher data speeds over ordinary
telephone lines, so users don't have to pay extra setup or monthly
costs for special lines, and telephone companies don't have to add
new equipment. ISPs benefit as they can now deliver the Web pages
and files that their users need at near-ISDN speeds and at nearly
twice the rate of the prevailing 28.8 standard. A few corporations
require costly technologies like ISDN for their telecommunications
and remote access needs. Meanwhile the vast majority of users,
including most businesses, will continue to use the cheapest and
easiest to install choice, voiceband modems, and their fastest
incarnation, the new 56 Kbps models, while the phone companies
begin deployment of ADSL.